Pilgrim Mill Way
Cumming, GA 30041 Upscale
24
Homes
1
Streets
$666,168
Avg Home
Address Directory
1 2090 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,620 sqft Secretary - Seeds Of Zion Organics INC. $791,720 View on Zillow →
1 2090 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,620 sqft
Secretary - Seeds Of Zion Organics INC.
$791,720
2 2095 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,731 sqft 1 vehicle $423,290 View on Zillow →
2 2095 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,731 sqft
1 vehicle
$423,290
3 2140 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,184 sqft $970,260 View on Zillow →
3 2140 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,184 sqft
$970,260
4 2150 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,869 sqft 1 vehicle General Partner - Charles L. Burks Iii Flp, LP $1,074,300 View on Zillow →
4 2150 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,869 sqft
1 vehicle General Partner - Charles L. Burks Iii Flp, LP
$1,074,300
5 2175 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,918 sqft 1 vehicle $558,280 View on Zillow →
5 2175 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,918 sqft
1 vehicle
$558,280
6 2180 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,220 sqft $598,440 View on Zillow →
6 2180 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,220 sqft
$598,440
7 2185 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,716 sqft $429,830 View on Zillow →
7 2185 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,716 sqft
$429,830
8 2210 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,188 sqft $629,090 View on Zillow →
8 2210 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,188 sqft
$629,090
9 2215 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,996 sqft $613,810 View on Zillow →
9 2215 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,996 sqft
$613,810
10 2230 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,768 sqft 1 vehicle Officer - C.l. Mccrary & Associates, INC... $850,980 View on Zillow →
10 2230 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,768 sqft
1 vehicle Officer - C.l. Mccrary & Associates, INC...
$850,980
11 2240 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,680 sqft 1 vehicle Officer - Vickery Investment Group, LLC $718,570 View on Zillow →
11 2240 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,680 sqft
1 vehicle Officer - Vickery Investment Group, LLC
$718,570
12 2255 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,560 sqft $420,150 View on Zillow →
12 2255 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,560 sqft
$420,150
13 2257 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,900 sqft 1 vehicle $420,470 View on Zillow →
13 2257 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,900 sqft
1 vehicle
$420,470
14 2260 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,460 sqft 1 vehicle $697,310 View on Zillow →
14 2260 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,460 sqft
1 vehicle
$697,310
15 2270 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 3,556 sqft CFO - Centerpoint It, INC. $1,212,310 View on Zillow →
15 2270 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 3,556 sqft
CFO - Centerpoint It, INC.
$1,212,310
16 2280 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,173 sqft $850,490 View on Zillow →
16 2280 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,173 sqft
$850,490
17 2290 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,243 sqft $974,450 View on Zillow →
17 2290 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,243 sqft
$974,450
18 2295 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,560 sqft 3 vehicles CEO - Global Touch Systems, INC. $590,710 View on Zillow →
18 2295 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,560 sqft
3 vehicles CEO - Global Touch Systems, INC.
$590,710
19 2310 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,638 sqft 3 vehicles
Licensed Salesperson CFO - Thompson Painting, INC. $667,040 View on Zillow →
19 2310 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,638 sqft
3 vehicles
Licensed Salesperson CFO - Thompson Painting, INC.
$667,040
20 2315 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,452 sqft 1 business $477,110 View on Zillow →
20 2315 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,452 sqft
1 business
$477,110
21 2325 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,572 sqft Officer - Planet Earth Designs LLC $546,130 View on Zillow →
21 2325 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 2,572 sqft
Officer - Planet Earth Designs LLC
$546,130
22 2330 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,288 sqft 3 vehicles Officer - Magnum Enterprises Etc., INC. $599,730 View on Zillow →
22 2330 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,288 sqft
3 vehicles Officer - Magnum Enterprises Etc., INC.
$599,730
23 2340 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,805 sqft $581,250 View on Zillow →
23 2340 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,805 sqft
$581,250
24 2350 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,212 sqft $618,470 View on Zillow →
24 2350 Pilgrim Mill Way
· 1,212 sqft
$618,470
Source: County assessor records, public records & state business filings · Updated Feb 2026
Loading map...
Explore Nearby in Cumming
Discover other neighborhoods in Cumming, GA and compare what they have to offer.
Schools & Education
Part of Forsyth County School District. 3 nearby schools serving this area.
E
Elementary Mashburn Elementary School
Score 69/100
Enrollment 600
Distance 0.3 mi
M
Middle Lakeside Middle School
Score 69/100
Enrollment 1,214
Distance 0.5 mi
H
High School North Forsyth High School
Enrollment 2,420
Distance 0.6 mi
Source: National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) · Updated Feb 2026
At a Glance
Avg Home Value
$666,168
Est. Monthly Cost
$3,647
$3,369 mortgage · N/A tax
Best School
69/100
3 nearby schools
Stability
Stable
24 homes · 1 street
Pilgrim Mill Way exhibits moderate stability with a mix of long-term and newer residents.
Continue Your Research
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average home value in Pilgrim Mill Way?
The average assessed property value in Pilgrim Mill Way is $666,168, with average annual property taxes of N/A.
What school district is Pilgrim Mill Way in?
Pilgrim Mill Way is served by Forsyth County School District. The highest-rated nearby school scores 69/100.
How many homes are in Pilgrim Mill Way?
Pilgrim Mill Way in Cumming, GA has 24 homes across 1 street.
Is Pilgrim Mill Way good for families?
Pilgrim Mill Way is served by Forsyth County School District (top school score: 69/100), average home value of $666,168. The neighborhood has 24 homes across 1 street, providing a close-knit community for families.
How much does it cost to live in Pilgrim Mill Way?
The average assessed home value is $666,168, and the estimated total monthly housing cost (mortgage, taxes, and insurance) is approximately $3,647. These estimates are based on a 30-year mortgage at 6.5% with 20% down.
What elementary school serves Pilgrim Mill Way?
The nearest elementary school is Mashburn Elementary School, located 0.3 miles away. It has 600 students enrolled.
What high school serves Pilgrim Mill Way?
The nearest high school is North Forsyth High School, located 0.6 miles away.
Is Pilgrim Mill Way a stable neighborhood?
Pilgrim Mill Way has a stability score of 55/100, classified as "Stable." This indicates moderate stability with some residential turnover.
Data Sources & Methodology
6 verified data sources power this report
Property tax & valuation records
Federal education statistics
Healthcare facility & outcome data
Transportation & hazard data
5-year community survey estimates
Housing market indicators
Last updated:
View full methodologyGet Neighborhood Updates
Stay informed about changes in Pilgrim Mill Way.
Overview